Peer Review Process

Peer Review Process

Type of review. The journal uses double-blind peer review. The identities of authors and reviewers are hidden from each other throughout the process. 

Stages.

  1. Technical check (within 7 days). The editorial office checks scope, template, authorship and declarations. It runs a similarity check with Turnitin (the similarity index must not exceed 20%, excluding references) and verifies a sample of 5 to 10 references to confirm that each can be found.
  2. Editor screening. An editor assesses originality, the research gap and methodological soundness, and either rejects the manuscript or sends it to review.
  3. Double-blind review. At least two independent reviewers assess the manuscript. A third reviewer is invited when their recommendations conflict.
  4. Decision. The Editor-in-Chief decides on the basis of the reviewers' reports: accept, minor revision, major revision, or decline.
  5. Revision. Authors submit a revised manuscript with a point-by-point response. Manuscripts that required major revision are returned to the reviewers.
  6. Production. Accepted manuscripts are copyedited and proofread before publication.

Reviewer qualifications. Reviewers hold at least a doctoral degree or have an equivalent publication record in the topic. They are not affiliated with the authors' institution and have no conflict of interest. Reviewers who cannot assess a manuscript objectively must decline.

Review criteria. Reviewers assess (a) the novelty and the stated research gap, (b) the suitability of the methods and data, (c) the depth of analysis and the comparison of findings with earlier studies, (d) whether the conclusion answers the objective, (e) the quality and currency of references (at least 15, mostly primary sources), and (f) the language. Reviewer comments must be substantive, not limited to grammar and layout.

Time limits. Reviewers are asked to return a report within 3 weeks. Authors are normally informed of the first decision within 8 weeks of submission.

Decision and independence. The Editor-in-Chief makes the final decision. An editor who is an author, or who has a conflict of interest, takes no part in the handling of that manuscript. Such manuscripts are handled by an independent editor and independent reviewers. The journal does not promise acceptance, does not offer fast-track publication, and does not issue a letter of acceptance before the final decision.

Records. All reviews, decisions and correspondence are handled in the journal's Open Journal Systems account and kept as evidence of review for each published article.

Appeals. Authors may appeal a decision once, in writing to the Editor-in-Chief at jurnaliptekspspuh@gmail.com, with a reasoned response to the reviewers' points.

Reviewer guidelines

Reviewers must keep the manuscript confidential, declare any conflict of interest, and decline if it is outside their expertise. They must not upload the manuscript or any part of it to an artificial intelligence tool (see the AI Policy page of this journal). They should cite relevant work the authors missed, and flag suspected plagiarism, duplicate submission or data problems to the editor.