Environmental Governance Challenges of Indigenous Forest Recognition: Climate Solution Ideal and Its Uneven Outcomes in Indonesia
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.24259/fs.v8i2.34423Keywords:
Indigenous land rights, Recognition, Environmental governance, Ammatoa Kajang, Climate solutions, Property, Forest conservation, Community-based resource managementAbstract
Formal policies on Indigenous land and forest rights recognition are increasingly being promoted as a climate solution in global forums. While this suggests a clear discursive victory for environmental justice movements, there has been less attention on the aftermaths of recognition. This in part owes to the novelty of policies on Indigenous land and forest recognition, but also due to the tendency among proponents to view formal legal victories as a means and ends of advocacy. In this paper, we spotlight what happens after recognition in Kajang, the site of the first Indigenous community to formally regain authority over state forests in Indonesia. We apply a lens from political ecology and draw from critical research on land and property to identify the unevenness of an emerging climate policy solution. Through grounded village-level research engagements lasting over three years in the span of over a decade, we identify a range of ethnographic perspectives on land, resources, authority, and shifting identity formation. Results highlight three main findings. First, while the assumption of community-based initiatives presumes the restoration of rights, new forms of enclosure and marginalization occur vis-à-vis policies of Indigenous land rights recognition. Second, the assumption of forest and environmental stewardship is by no means automatic, as land and resource concerns have a geographic dimension that may result in protection for some forests at the expense of others. Finally, Kajang is unique for its history and political economy making it difficult to assume parallel outcomes elsewhere. While environmental justice movements should continue to advocate for Indigeneity and forest and land recognition, more attention should be given to their underlying strategies and the implications of doing so.
References
Afiff, S., & Lowe, C. (2007). Claiming Indigenous Community: Political Discourse and Natural Resource Rights in Indonesia. Alternatives: Global, Local, Political, 32(1), 73–97. https://doi.org/10.1177/030437540703200104
Agrawal, A. (2005). Environmentality. Current Anthropology, 46(2), 161–190. https://doi.org/10.1086/427122
APF, & OHCHR. (2013). The United Nations declaration on the rights of indigenous peoples : a manual for national rights institutions. United Nations.
Brosius, J. P., Tsing, A. L., & Zerner, C. (1998). Representing communities: Histories and politics of community‐based natural resource management. Society & Natural Resources, 11(2), 157–168. https://doi.org/10.1080/08941929809381069
Burkey, S. (1993). People First: A Guide to Self-Reliant Participatory Rural Development. Zed Books.
Carling, J., Itongwa, J., & Jintiach, J. C. (2023). 2023’s top 10 Indigenous news stories (commentary). Mongabay. https://news.mongabay.com/2023/12/2023s-top-10-indigenous-news-stories-commentary/
Cense, A. (1931). De Patoentoengs in Het Bergland van Kadjang. Verhandelingen van Het Koninklijk Instituut Voor Taal-, Land- En Volkenkunde.
Chen, C. W. (2014). Indigenous Rights in International Law. In Oxford Research Encyclopedia of International Studies. Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190846626.013.77
Cox, M., Arnold, G., & Villamayor Tomás, S. (2010). A Review of Design Principles for Community-based Natural Resource Management. Ecology and Society, 15(4), art38. https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-03704-150438
Davidson, J., & Henley, D. (2007). The Revival of Tradition in Indonesian Politics (1st Edition). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203965498
Donselaar, W. M. (1854). Beknopte Beschrijving Van Bonthain en Boelecomba op Zuid Celebes. Bijdragen Tot de Taal-, Land- En Volkenkunde van Nederlandsch-Indië, 3(2), 163–187. http://www.jstor.org/stable/25733701
Dove, M. (2011). The banana tree at the gate: a history of marginal peoples and global markets in Borneo. Yale University Press.
Dove, M., Sajise, P., & Doolittle, A. (2011). Beyond the Sacred Forest: Complicating Conservation in Southeast Asia. Duke University Press.
Erazo, J. S. (2013). Governing Indigenous Territories: Enacting Sovereignty in the Ecuadorian Amazon: Enacting Sovereignty in the Ecuadorian Amazon. Duke University Press. https://doi.org/10.1515/9780822378921
Erbaugh, J. T. (2019). Responsibilization and social forestry in Indonesia. Forest Policy and Economics, 109, 102019. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.forpol.2019.102019
Ferguson, J. (1994). Anti-politics machine: Development, depoliticization, and bureaucratic power in Lesotho. University of Minnesota Press.
Fernández-Llamazares, Á., Fa, J. E., Brockington, D., Brondízio, E. S., Cariño, J., Corbera, E., ... & Garnett, S. T. (2024). No basis for claim that 80% of biodiversity is found in Indigenous territories. Nature, 633(8028), 32-35. https://doi.org/ 10.1038/d41586-024-02811-w
Fisher, M. (2019). Beyond Recognition: Indigenous Land Rights and Changing Landscapes in Indonesia [Doctoral Dissertation]. University of Hawai’i.
Fisher, M. (2021). Engaging voices in the landscape: Participatory geography in Indigenous land rights recognition. In S. Acabado & D.-W. Kuan (Eds.), Indigenous Peoples, Heritage and Landscape in the Asia Pacific (pp. 31–53). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003126690
Fisher, M. R., & Muur, W. van der. (2019). Misleading Icons of Communal Lands in Indonesia: Implications of Adat Forest Recognition From a Model Site in Kajang, Sulawesi. The Asia Pacific Journal of Anthropology, 21(1), 55–76. https://doi.org/10.1080/14442213.2019.1670244
Fisher, M. R., Dhiaulhaq, A., & Sahide, M. A. K. (2019). The politics, economies, and ecologies of Indonesia’s third generation of social forestry: An introduction to the special section. Forest and society, 3(1), 152-170. http://dx.doi.org/10.24259/fs.v3i1.6348
Fisher, M. R., Workman, T., Mulyana, A., Institute, B., Moeliono, M., Yuliani, E. L., ... & Adam, U. E. F. B. (2020). Striving for PAR excellence in land use planning: Multi-stakeholder collaboration on customary forest recognition in Bulukumba, South Sulawesi. Land Use Policy, 99, 102997. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol. 2017.09.057
Fisher, M., Mulyana, A., Labarani, A., Kamaluddin, Yuliana, L., & Moeliono, M. (2023). The power of possibility in landscape governance: Multiple lives of participatory action research in Kajang, Sulawesi. In C. J. P. Colfer & R. Prabhu (Eds.), Responding to Environmental Issues through Adaptive Collaborative Management: From Forest Communities to Global Actors (1st ed., pp. 113–132). Routledge.
Fletcher, R. (2017). Environmentality unbound: Multiple governmentalities in environmental politics. Geoforum, 85, 311–315. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. geoforum.2017.06.009
Gilbert, J. (2007). Indigenous Rights in the Making: The United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. International Journal on Minority and Group Rights, 14(2–3), 207–230. https://doi.org/10.1163/138548707X208818
Gilbert, J. (2013). Land Rights as Human Rights: The Case for a Specific Right to Land. SSRN Electronic Journal. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2401190
Gilmour, D. (2016). Forty years of community-based forestry: A review of its extent and effectiveness. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations.
Hall, D., Hirsch, P., & Li, T. M. (2011). Powers of Exclusion: Land Dilemmas in Southeast Asia. University of Hawai’i Press.
Harvey, B. S. (1974). Tradition, Islam, and rebellion: South Sulawesi 1950-1965. Cornell University Press.
Hecht, S., & Cockburn, A. (2010). The fate of the forest: developers, destroyers, and defenders of the Amazon. University of Chicago Press.
Heynen, N., McCarthy, J., Prudham, S., & Robbins, P. (2007). Neoliberal Environments (N. Heynen, J. McCarthy, S. Prudham, & P. Robbins, Eds.). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203946848
Jones, G. (2002). Merchants to Multinationals: British Trading Companies in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries. Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10. 1093/0199249997.001.0001
Jones, G., & Wale, J. (1998). Merchants as Business Groups: British Trading Companies in Asia before 1945. Business History Review, 72(3), 367–408. https://doi.org/ 10.2307/3116215
Kenney-Lazar, M., Johnson, A., Sultana, F., Himley, M., Bebbington, A. J., Havice, E., Rice, J., & Osborne, T. (2023). Relational environmental governance: A critical framework for praxis with the material world. Journal of Political Ecology, 30(1). https://doi.org/10.2458/jpe.5542
Knox, A., & Meinzen-Dick, R. (2000). Collective action, property rights, and devolution of natural resource management: exchange of knowledge and implications for policy. CAPRi Working Paper 11. IFPRI. http://dx.doi.org/10.22004/ag.econ. 55437
KOMNAS HAM. (2006). Proses Mediasi Lahan Tanah Adat Bulukumba Provinsi Sulawesi Selatan. KOMNAS HAM.
Kronik, J., & Verner, D. (2010). Indigenous peoples and climate change in Latin America and the Caribbean. World Bank Publication.
Larson, A. M., & Ribot, J. C. (2004). Democratic Decentralisation through a Natural Resource Lens: An Introduction. The European Journal of Development Research, 16(1), 1–25. https://doi.org/10.1080/09578810410001688707
Larson, A. M., & Soto, F. (2008). Decentralization of Natural Resource Governance Regimes. Annual Review of Environment and Resources, 33(1), 213–239. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.environ.33.020607.095522
Lemos, M. C., & Agrawal, A. (2006). Environmental Governance. Annual Review of Environment and Resources, 31(1), 297–325. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev. energy.31.042605.135621
Li, T. M. (2002). Engaging Simplifications: Community-Based Resource Management, Market Processes and State Agendas in Upland Southeast Asia. World Development, 30(2), 265–283. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0305-750X(01)00103-6
Li, T. M. (2007). The will to improve: Governmentality, development, and the practice of politics. duke university Press.
Li, T. M. (2010). Indigeneity, Capitalism, and the Management of Dispossession. Current Anthropology, 51(3), 385–414. https://doi.org/10.1086/651942
Li, T. M. (2014). Land’s End: Capitalist Relations on an Indigenous Frontier. In Capitalist Relations on an Indigenous Frontier. Duke University Press. https://doi.org/10. 1515/9780822376460
Maarif, S. (2012). Dimensions of religious practice: the Ammatoans of Sulawesi, Indonesia [Doctoral Dissertation]. Arizona State University.
Menon, A., Singh, P., Shah, E., Lélé, S., Paranjape, S., & Joy, K. (2007). Community-Based Natural Resource Management: Issues and Cases from South Asia. SAGE Publications India Pvt Ltd. https://doi.org/10.4135/9788132101550
Milne, S. (2022). Corporate Nature. University of Arizona Press. https://doi.org/ 10.2307/j.ctv37scfkf
Moeliono, M., Thuy, P. T., Bong, I. W., Wong, G. Y., & Brockhaus, M. (2017). Social Forestry-why and for whom? A comparison of policies in Vietnam and Indonesia. Forest and Society, 1(2), 78-97. http://dx.doi.org/10.24259/fs.v1i2.2484
Mulyotami, E., Wahyuni, E. S., & Kolopaking, L. M. (2014). Mengurai Jaringan Migrasi: Kajian Komunitas Petani Migran Bugis Di Sulawesi Tenggara” [Unraveling the Migration Network: Study of Buginese Migrant Community in Southeast Sulawesi]. Jurnal Kependudukan Indonesia, 9(1), 10–24.
Muur, W. E. van der. (2019). Land Rights and the Forces of Adat in Democratizing Indonesia [Doctoral Dissertation]. Van Vollenhoven Institute, Leiden University.
Muur, W. Van der, & Bedner, A. (2016). Traditional Rule as “Modern Governance”: Recognizing The Ammatoa Kajang Adat Law Community. Mimbar Hukum - Fakultas Hukum Universitas Gadjah Mada, 28(1), 149. https://doi.org/10.22146/ jmh.15871
Myers, R., Intarini, D., Sirait, M. T., & Maryudi, A. (2017). Claiming the forest: Inclusions and exclusions under Indonesia’s ‘new’ forest policies on customary forests. Land Use Policy, 66, 205–213. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2017.04.039
Nakayama, H., Rustiadi, E., & Fauzi, A. (2024). Does Social Forestry Contribute to Farmers’ Income?: A Case Study of Two Mountainous Villages on Java Island, Indonesia. Journal of Regional and Rural Development Planning, 8(1), 1–10. https://doi.org/10.29244/jp2wd.2024.8.1.1-10
Neumann, R. P. (1998). Imposing Wilderness: Struggles over Livelihood and Nature Preservation in Africa (Vol. 4). University of California Press.
Ostrom, E. (1990). Governing the commons: The evolution of institutions for collective action. Cambridge University Press.
Ostrom, E. (2009). Understanding Institutional Diversity. Princeton University Press.
Peet, R., & Watts, M. (2004). Liberation Ecologies: Environment, Development and Social Movements (R. Peet & M. Watts, Eds.; 2nd edition). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203235096
Peluso, N. L. (1993). Coercing conservation? Global Environmental Change, 3(2), 199–217. https://doi.org/10.1016/0959-3780(93)90006-7
Peluso, N. L., & Lund, C. (2011). New frontiers of land control: Introduction. Journal of Peasant Studies, 38(4), 667–681. https://doi.org/10.1080/03066150.2011. 607692
Peluso, N. L., & Vandergeest, P. (2001). Genealogies of the Political Forest and Customary Rights in Indonesia, Malaysia, and Thailand. The Journal of Asian Studies, 60(3), 761–812. https://doi.org/10.2307/2700109
Perkasa, V., & Evanty, N. (2014). The World Conference on Indigenous Peoples: A View From Indonesia. Council on Foreign Relations.
Pratt Miles, J. D. (2013). Designing Collaborative Processes for Adaptive Management: Four Structures for Multistakeholder Collaboration. Ecology and Society, 18(4), art5. https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-05709-180405
Prill-Brett, J. (2007). Contested Domains: The Indigenous Peoples Rights Act (IPRA) and Legal Pluralism in the Northern Philippines. The Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial Law, 39(55), 11–36. https://doi.org/10.1080/07329113.2007. 10756606
Rachman, N. F., & Siscawati, M. (2014). Masyarakat Hukum Adat adalah Penyandang Hak, Subjek Hukum, dan Pemilik Wilayah Adatnya: Memahami Secara Kontekstual Putusan Mahkamah Konstitusi Republik Indonesia atas perkara nomor 35/PU-X/2012. Insist Press.
RECOFTC. (2020). Social forestry and climate change in the ASEAN region. In: Situational Analysis 2020. RECOFTC.
Ribot, J. (2002). Democratic decentralization of natural resources: Institutionalizing popular participation. World Resource Institute.
Ribot, J. C. (2003). Democratic decentralisation of natural resources: institutional choice and discretionary power transfers in Sub‐Saharan Africa. Public Administration and Development, 23(1), 53–65. https://doi.org/10.1002/pad.259
Ribot, J. C., & Peluso, N. L. (2003). A theory of access. Rural sociology, 68(2), 153-181. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1549-0831.2003.tb00133.x
Ribot, J., & Larson, A. M. (2012). Affirmative policy on an uneven playing field. International Journal of the Commons, 6(2), 233–254. https://doi.org/10.18352/ ijc.322
Roe, D., Nelson, F., & Sandbrook, C. (2009). Community management of natural resources in Africa: Impacts, experiences and future directions. International Institute for Environment and Development (IIED).
Sahide, M. A. K., Fisher, M. R., Erbaugh, J. T., Intarini, D., Dharmiasih, W., Makmur, M., …, & Maryudi, A. (2020a). The boom of social forestry policy and the bust of social forests in Indonesia: Developing and applying an access-exclusion framework to assess policy outcomes. Forest Policy and Economics, 120, 102290. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.forpol.2020.102290
Sahide, M. A. K., Fisher, M. R., Supratman, S., Yusran, Y., Pratama, A. A., Maryudi, A., ... & Kim, Y. S. (2020b). Prophets and profits in Indonesia's social forestry partnership schemes: Introducing a sequential power analysis. Forest Policy and Economics, 115, 102160. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.forpol.2020.102160
Santika, T., Meijaard, E., Budiharta, S., Law, E. A., Kusworo, A., Hutabarat, J. A., …, & Wilson, K. A. (2017). Community forest management in Indonesia: Avoided deforestation in the context of anthropogenic and climate complexities. Global Environmental Change, 46, 60–71. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2017. 08.002
Sauer, C. O. (1963). Land and Life (J. Leighly, Ed.). University of California Press. https://doi.org/10.2307/jj.13167997
Saunders, F. P. (2014). The promise of common pool resource theory and the reality of commons projects. International Journal of the Commons, 8(2), 636. https://doi.org/10.18352/ijc.477
Scheltema, A. M. P. A. (1931). Deelbouw in Nederlandsch-Indie [Dissertation]. Wageningen University.
SNUB. (2003). Kronologis: Kasus Penembakan Petani Dan Masyarakat Adat Kajang Bulukumba Propinsi Sulawesi Selatan Oleh Aparat POLDA Sulawesi Selatan Dan Polres Bulukumba 21 Juli 2003. SNUB.
Swepston, L. (1990). A New Step in the International Law on Indigenous and Tribal Peoples: ILO Convention No. 169 of 1989. Oklohama City University Law Review, 15(3), 677.
Sylvain, R. (2014). Essentialism and the Indigenous Politics of Recognition in Southern Africa. American Anthropologist, 116(2), 251–264. https://doi.org/10.1111/ aman.12087
Tusing, C., & Leemann, E. (2023). Time as the Enemy? Disjointed Timelines and Uneven Rhythms of Indigenous Collective Land Titling in Paraguay and Cambodia. Land, 12(8), 1620. https://doi.org/10.3390/land12081620
Tyson, A. D. (2008). The politics of decentralisation and indigenous revivalism in Sulawesi, Indonesia [Doctoral Dissertation]. University of Leeds.
Tyson, A. D. (2010). Decentralization and Adat Revivalism in Indonesia. Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203849903
Ubink, J. M., & Quan, J. F. (2008). How to combine tradition and modernity? Regulating customary land management in Ghana. Land Use Policy, 25(2), 198–213. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2007.06.002
Wenk, I. (2012). Ancestral domain: land titling and the conjuncture of government, rights and territory in central Mindanao [Doctoral Dissertation]. University of Zurich.
West, P., Igoe, J., & Brockington, D. (2006). Parks and Peoples: The Social Impact of Protected Areas. Annual Review of Anthropology, 35(1), 251–277. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.anthro.35.081705.123308
Workman, T., Fisher, M., Mulyana, A., Moeliono, M., Yuliani, E. L., & Balang. (2015). Out of the Lion’s Den, Into the Crocodile’s Jaws?: Lessons from policy developments on customary forest in Bulukumba (56). World Agroforestry Centre (ICRAF) Southeast Asia Regional Program.
Additional Files
Published
Issue
Section
Categories
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Forest and Society
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
This is an open access journal which means that all contents is freely available without charge to the user or his/her institution. Users are allowed to read, download, copy, distribute, print, search, or link to the full texts of the articles in this journal without asking prior permission from the publisher or the author. This is in accordance with the BOAI definition of open access.
Submission of an article implies that the work described has not been published previously (except in the form of an abstract or as part of a published lecture or academic thesis), that it is not under consideration for publication elsewhere, that its publication is approved by all authors and tacitly or explicitly by the responsible authorities where the work was carried out, and that, if accepted, will not be published elsewhere in the same form, in English or in any other language, without the written consent of the Publisher. An article based on a section from a completed graduate dissertation may be published in Forest and Society, but only if this is allowed by author's(s') university rules. The Editors reserve the right to edit or otherwise alter all contributions, but authors will receive proofs for approval before publication.
Forest and Society operates a CC-BY 4.0 © license for journal papers. Copyright remains with the author, but Forest and Society is licensed to publish the paper, and the author agrees to make the article available with the CC-BY 4.0 license. Reproduction as another journal article in whole or in part would be plagiarism. Forest and Society reserves all rights except those granted in this copyright notice
