Multivariate Risk Analysis of Echotoxic Chemicals of Ballast Water Chemicals Based on PCA and DSS Using ECOTOX GISIS Data
Main Article Content
Abstract
This study proposes a multivariate risk classification model for ballast water treatment chemicals by integrating global datasets—ECOTOX (U.S. EPA) and GISIS (IMO). Using Principal Component Analysis (PCA), we analyze 37 substances based on acute toxicity (LC50), chronic toxicity (NOEC), and bioaccumulation potential (BCF). The aim is to provide a practical, data-driven tool to support ecological compliance, early warnings, and regulatory prioritization in maritime chemical management. Results show that 43.24% of substances fall into the high-risk category, while only 8.11% are low risk. PCA effectively reduces dimensionality, explaining 73.63% of variance with just two components. High-risk chemicals such as Dibromoacetic acid and Dichloroacetonitrile exhibit low NOEC and high BCF values—indicating significant ecotoxic potential, often underregulated. Some commonly used oxidants also reveal hidden chronic toxicity, suggesting gaps in current risk frameworks post-BWM Convention. We construct a risk-scoring matrix and chemical heatmap to visualize ecotoxic profiles, enabling real-time risk ranking and decision support. Unlike previous studies that focus solely on toxicity thresholds or narrative reviews, this approach integrates empirical data with decision logic to aid Port State Control (PSC) and IMO policy design. The method is replicable and adaptable to other maritime pollutants, especially in the ASEAN context, enhancing smart port readiness and ecological safeguarding.
Downloads
Article Details

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Accepted 2025-07-19
Published 2025-10-08
References
[1]. Growcott, A., Kluza, D., Georgiades, E. (2017) Review: In-Water Systems To Reactively Manage Biofouling In Sea Chests And Internal Pipework Marine Technology Society Journal 51, 89-104
[2]. Sabra, F., Mehana, E. (2015) Pesticides Toxicity In Fish With Particular Reference To Insecticides Asian Journal Of Agriculture And Food Sciences 3
[3]. Borrely, S., I., Jm, R., Boiani, N., F., Vsg, G., Al, S. (2018) Emerging Pollutants, Related Toxicity, And Water Quality Decreasing: Tannery, Textile, And Pharmaceuticals Load Pollutants Bioelectromagnetics 3
[4]. Sorokina, T. (2024) International Law Issues Concerning Marine Environment Protection In The Arctic Moscow Journal Of International Law
[5]. Ite, A., E., Ite, I., A. (2024) Organic Micropollutants In The Air: Origin And Occurence, Environmental And Health Effects, And Mitigation Strategies Environment &Amp; Ecosystem Science
[6]. Tsimplis, M. (2020) Regulatory Systems Supporting Innovation: Lessons From The Development Of The 2004 Ballast Water Management Convention The International Journal Of Marine And Coastal Law -1, 1-29
[7]. Outinen, O., Bailey, S., A., Casas-Monroy, O., Delacroix, S., Gorgula, S., Griniene, E., Kakkonen, J., Srėbalienė, G. (2024) Biological Testing Of Ships’ Ballast Water Indicates Challenges For The Implementation Of The Ballast Water Management Convention Frontiers In Marine Science
[8]. Onwurah, O., O. (2024) ‘Challenges And Regulatory Precautionary Approach Of Flag States In Implementing Obligations Under The Ballast Water Management Convention’ International Journal Of Research And Innovation In Social Science
[9]. Nordquist, M., Nandan, S., Kraska, J. (2012) Other Supplementary Documents And Materials Implications Of The United Nations Convention On The Law Of The Sea For The International Maritime Organization, Imo Doc. Leg/Misc.6, 2008 , 739-883
[10]. Peet, G. (1994) The Role Of (Environmental) Non-Governmental Organizations At The Marine Environment Protection Committee (Mepc) Of The International Maritime Organization (Imo), And At The London Dumping Convention (Ldc) Ocean & Coastal Management 22, 3-18
[11]. Turčinović, F., Kovačević, A., Mijović, B. (2019) Legislative Activity Of The International Maritime Organization (Imo) China-Usa Business Review
[12]. Qiu, P., Huang, M., Wu, S., Wen, M., Yu, N., Chen, Z. (2022) Dynamic Effects Of Endo-Exogenous Stimulations On Enzyme-Activatable Polymeric Nanosystems With Photo-Sono-Chemo Synergy. Acs Applied Materials & Interfaces
[13]. Chen, X., Jaiswal, A., Costliow, Z., A., Herbst, P., Creasey, E., Oshiro-Rapley, N., Daly, M., J., Carey, K., Graham, D., Xavier, R. (2022) Ph Sensing Controls Tissue Inflammation By Modulating Cellular Metabolism And Endo-Lysosomal Function Of Immune Cells Nature Immunology 23, 1063-1075
[14]. Chen, T., Yi, J., Zhao, Y., Chu, X. (2018) Biomineralized Metal-Organic Framework Nanoparticles Enable Intracellular Delivery And Endo-Lysosomal Release Of Native Active Proteins. Journal Of The American Chemical Society 140 31, 9912-9920
[15]. Turner, T., Tonge, D., Glanville, H., Wheeler, R., Oliver, I., W. (2023) Microbial Genome (Illumina Miseq) Sequencing Of Drinking Water Treatment Residuals To Evaluate Compatibility With Environmental Applications Environmental Monitoring And Assessment 195
[16]. Zhou, L., Wallace, S., M., Kroll, K., Denslow, N., Gaillard, J., Meyer, P., Bonzongo, J. (2021) Acute And Chronic Toxicity Testing Of Drinking Water Treatment Residuals In Freshwater Systems Environmental Toxicology And Chemistry 40
[17]. Gavrilova, A., Gerasimov, A., Sladkova, S., Samulenkov, D. (2024) Assessment Of The Environmental Safety Of The Ship Ballast Water Treated By Ozone Ecology And Industry Of Russia
[18]. Eldridge, R., J., Jourdan, B., D., D., Hanson, M. (2021) A Critical Review Of The Availability, Reliability, And Ecological Relevance Of Arctic Species Toxicity Tests For Use In Environmental Risk Assessment Environmental Toxicology And Chemistry 41, 46-72
[19]. Lang, C., Dieen, J., H., V., Brodie, M., Welzel, J., Maetzler, W., Singh, N., B., Ravi, D., K. (2024) Complexities And Challenges Of Translating Intervention Success To Real World Gait In People With Parkinson’s Disease Frontiers In Neurology 15
[20]. Wood, J., K. (2023) Affect Dynamics In Context: A Hierarchical Bayesian Ar Model For A Lab-Based Paradigm Multivariate Behavioral Research 58, 137-138
[21]. Ho, Y. (2023) Comments On “Unveiling The Recycling Characteristics And Trends Of Spent Lithium-Ion Battery: A Scientometric Study” By Li, Guangming Et Al., Doi (Https://Doi.Org/10.1007/S11356-021–17,814-7) Environmental Science And Pollution Research 30, 51370
[22]. Mckeon, J., W., Trumbull, K., M., Hughes, J., L. (2024) Correction To Mckeon Et Al. (2020) Psi Chi Journal Of Psychological Research
[23]. Guo, Q., Gu, X., Feng, K., Huang, J., Du, L. (2022) Response To Kim Et Al. “When Conducting A Systematic Review, Can One Trade Search Efficiency For Potential Publication Bias?” Research Synthesis Methods 13
[24]. Liu, C., Ali, N. (2022) Co-Citation And Bibliographic Coupling Based On Connected Papers: Review Of Public Opinion Research In A Broad Sense In The West Asian Social Science
[25]. Lu, Y., Yuan, M., Liu, J., Chen, M. (2023) Research On Semantic Representation And Citation Recommendation Of Scientific Papers With Multiple Semantics Fusion Scientometrics 128, 1367-1393
[26]. Chen, H., Bornmann, L., Bu, Y. (2025) Dynamic Disruption Index Across Citation And Cited References Windows: Recommendations For Thresholds In Research Evaluation Arxiv Abs/2504.07828
[27]. Endo, T., Kanoto, O., Matsunaga, N., Fukui, K., Suzuki, M. (2017) United States Patent ( 19 ) Endo Et Al . 54 Self-Lubricating Polyacetal Wear Part ( 75 ) Inventors : Toshihiko
[28]. Osuka, A., Miyao, D., Kuroki, Y. (2020) Comment On “Volume-Outcome Relationship On Survival And Cost Benefits In Severe Burn Injury: A Retrospective Analysis Of A Japanese Nationwide Administrative Database” (Endo Et Al., Journal Of Intensive Care 2019) Journal Of Intensive Care 8
[29]. Li, J., Li, Q., Wang, L., Wang, L. (2024) Letter To The Editor Regarding "High Whole-Body Bone Mineral Density In Ossification Of The Posterior Longitudinal Ligament" By Endo Et Al. The Spine Journal : Official Journal Of The North American Spine Society 24 3, 554-555
[30]. Bornmann, L., Haunschild, R. (2023) Reference Publication Year Spectroscopy (Rpys) Of Papers Published By Loet Leydesdorff: A Giant In The Field Of Scientometrics Passed Away El Profesional De La Información
[31]. Lechien, J., Hopkins, C., Saussez, S. (2020) Letter To The Editor About The Beltrán‐Corbellini Et Al. Publication: ‘Acute‐Onset Smell And Taste Disorders In The Context Of Covid‐19: A Pilot Multicenter Pcr‐Based Case‐Control Study’ (Eur J Neurol 2020. Doi: 10.1111/Ene.14273) European Journal Of Neurology 27, E33-E33
[32]. Wray, K., B., Paludan, S., R., Bornmann, L., Haunschild, R. (2024) Using Reference Publication Year Spectroscopy (Rpys) To Analyze The Research And Publication Culture In Immunology Scientometrics 129, 3271-3283
[33]. Ortiz-De-Urbina-Criado, M., Sapena, A., F., Ferrer, S., C., , , , , García, A., G., Qureshi, W., Al-Mallah, M. (2023) Research Data Publication And Citation Bibliography
[34]. Scheidsteger, T., Haunschild, R. (2019) Telling The Early Story Of Solar Energy Meteorology By Applying (Co-Citation) Reference Publication Year Spectroscopy Arxiv Abs/1902.09178
[35]. Scheidsteger, T., Haunschild, R. (2020) Telling The Story Of Solar Energy Meteorology Into The Satellite Era By Applying (Co-Citation) Reference Publication Year Spectroscopy Scientometrics 125, 1159-1177
[36]. , , Erausquin, L., A., D., Hirnstein, G., A., Weis, M., Hausmann, S., Alba-Ferrara, L., Erausquin, G., A., D., Hirnstein, M., Weis, S., Hausmann, M., Badcock, J., C., Leitman, D. (0) Citation For Published Item: Use Policy Emotional Prosody Modulates Attention In Schizophrenia Patients With Hallucinations
[37]. Smith, D., L., Perkins, T., Tusting, L., Scott, T., Lindsay, S. (0) Citation For Published Item: Publisher's Copyright Statement: Use Policy Mosquito Population Regulation And Larval Source Management In Heterogeneous Environments
[38]. Pride, D., Knoth, P. (2017) Incidental Or Influential? - Challenges In Automatically Detecting Citation Importance Using Publication Full Texts , 572-578
[39]. Agarwal, S., Ghosh, U., , , Sreevalsan-Nair, J. (0) Citevis : Visual Analysis Of Overlapping Citation Intents As Dynamic Sets
[40]. Ghosh, S., Agarwal, M., Ghosh, S., Dey, A. (2015) Aquagenic Palmar Wrinkling In Two Indian Patients With Special Reference To Its Dermoscopic Pattern. Dermatology Online Journal 21 6
[41]. Jani, R., H., Prabhu, A., Zhou, J., J., Alan, N., Agarwal, N. (2020) Citation Analysis Of The Most Influential Articles On Traumatic Spinal Cord Injury The Journal Of Spinal Cord Medicine 43, 31-38
[42]. Groote, S., L., D., Scoulas, J., Dempsey, P., R., Barrett, F., A. (2023) Factors Affecting Publication Impact And Citation Trends Over Time Evidence Based Library And Information Practice
[43]. Tomaszewski, R. (2023) Visibility, Impact, And Applications Of Bibliometric Software Tools Through Citation Analysis Scientometrics 128, 4007-4028
[44]. Eika, E., Sandnes, F. (2022) Starstruck By Journal Prestige And Citation Counts? On Students’ Bias And Perceptions Of Trustworthiness According To Clues In Publication References Scientometrics 127, 6363-6390